A highly collectible mint mistake is the 1943/2 Jefferson nickel. Maybe it was that the dies had eroded and were not replaced, or perhaps they were set too far apart. Sold: November 2016; Stack's/Bowers, November 2016 Baltimore Coin Auction. In addition, its natural toning around the rim enhances its beauty and appeal to coin collectors. 1971 Quarter Value (Rare Errors, D, S & No Mint Marks). This coin is the only one in the Buffalo nickel series with a significant doubling on the coin's reverse. The reason copper factors into the value of a nickel is because a standard Jefferson five-cent coin isnt made from just nickel. 2005 Nickels Worth Money. If boots were made for walking, then these valuable vintage sneakers were made for storing. 7.) Work on memorizing this list of years and you might be able to identify some valuable nickels easily. Some of our partners may process your data as a part of their legitimate business interest without asking for consent. One sold for $16,675 in 2008. Distilled, not diluted. The existing examples only have minor doubling, but these rare coins are worth between $25 and $100, but it is common for doubled die nickels to fetch more. 3.) While many years have a plentiful number of circulated and proof examples, 1867 is not the case. Jefferson nickels have been around for a long time, and they're in almost any handful of pocket change. Learn more about how we curate the best products for you. Nickels from this period include Liberty Head Nickels from 1883-1913, Buffalo Nickels from 1913-1938, Jefferson Nickels from 1938-2003, and Westward Journey Nickels from 2004-2006. Therefore, it is scarce in circulated grades and rare in mint state grades. Also worth noting silver nickels arent made entirely from silver. Although not rare, the Denver 1944 nickels are fewer than those minted in Philadelphia. Jefferson nickels made before 1960 old Jefferson nickels made in the 1930s, 1940s, and 1950s have a value of 10 cents or more except for the ones listed below All the Jefferson nickel values listed below are for coins in average circulated condition. Higher-grade pieces are worth more, and cleaned and damaged nickels are worth less. If you can identify the rarity, the history, and the condition of any nickel, then you will be able to conquer this hobby. The new coin was a hit, and in 1867 and 1868, nearly 30 million nickels were minted! The reverse die used to create it was polished a little too hard, and the iconic buffalo is missing a leg because of it. You can identify these coins by the large D mark at the top of the dome on Monticello. Im the Coin Editor here at TheFunTimesGuide. New and beginning collectors find the circulated pieces affordable and base collections on nice examples. In fact, for most of 1942, the 5-cent coin was made from nickel. In fact, the most valuable Jefferson nickels are worth thousands of dollars. These include: Lets now look at the value of each of these nickels. This overstamping makes the D over S nickel rare, and it's especially rare in the full steps version and near mint condition. The Most Valuable Nickels, 1942-D Over Horizontal D Jefferson Nickel, 1936-D Buffalo Nickel Three and a Half Legs, 1918/7-D Buffalo Nickel Doubled Die Obverse, 1964 Jefferson Nickel Mirror Brockage: $1,153,000, 1918/7-D Buffalo Nickel Doubled Die Obverse: $504,164, 1916 Buffalo Nickel Doubled Die Obverse: $432,198, 1935 Buffalo Nickel Doubled Die Reverse: $146,238, 1937-D Buffalo Nickel Three Legs: $107,749, 1936-D Buffalo Nickel Three and a Half Legs: $22,452, 1942-D Over Horizontal D Jefferson Nickel: $11,126, Button Up: These Chic Cardigans For Women Are Challenging The Stereotype, Lotus Cars: Pinnacle Of Precision Performance, All Is Good In The Hood: The Best Hoodies For Women, The Best Denim Jackets For Men To Rock With Everything In Your Closet, From Desk To Dinner: These Womens Leather Pants Own The Room, Ready For Action: 23 Best Everyday Carry Backpacks, Best Crossbodies For Women: Hands-free Convenience Never Looked So Stylish, Aston Martin: Sophisticated, Savvy Secret-Agent Style, Dont Sweat It: The Best Sweatshirts For Men, Rolls-Royce: Regal Rides Radiating Royal Respect, Warm Wonders: Make Space For These Sumptuous Sweaters, Hold On: These Clutch Bags Are Stealing The Show. The obverse, also known as the heads, is the top side of the coin. This post may contain affiliate links. Copper and Nickel Prices SOARING!Watch this video on YouTube, Stay up to date with everything about U.S Coins, We dont spam! At Luxe Digital, we independently research, review, and recommend products we love and that we think you will love, too. In Buffalo nickels, also known as Indian Head nickels, were in production from 1913 to 1938, making the majority of them somewhat rare today. Sifting through them all is an impossible task, but finding a valuable nickel isnt quite as hard as you would imagine. You can notice some trends in the years that are valuable and the mints they come from. The melt value of a $100 box of nickels from 1946-2014 was $75.86 on June 26, 2019. There are only 24 known examples with full steps, and one sold in 2019 for $24,000. In circulated condition, 1944 D nickels are worth between $1.25 and $4.25, while in uncirculated condition, this coin can fetch as much as $750. Back in 2004, one sold for $281,750, which is equal to about $431,200 in inflation-adjusted 2022 dollars. During the reverse coin die manufacturing, sloppy workmanship resulted in this die variety. All told, the U.S. Mint produces an average of 12 to 15 billion coins each year and the more they make, the lower the production costs per coin tend to be. This shows up especially well in the word "MONTICELLO" and in "FIVE CENTS." Advertise a display every week and get a monthly 10% discount. While the 1918 piece had the wrong year initially stamped on it, the 1916 nickel had the correct year mark, but it was stamped in two places. Ive authored nearly 1,000 articles here at The Fun Times Guide to Coins (many of them with over 50K shares), and I welcome your coin questions in the comments below! Im a member of the American Numismatic Association (ANA) and the Numismatic Literary Guild (NLG) and have won multiple awards from the NLG for my work as a coin journalist. 1927 S Buffalo Nickel - Worth $5,000. These old coins are out there in circulation, and I know this because Ive found many of them myself in pocket changeand in rolls of coins that Ive looked through over the years. To buy the food we eat, the house we live in, and the things we do. One sold for $16,450 in 2014. All rights reserved. A 1942 proof from the Philadelphia Mint exhibits exceptional contrast and is in beautiful shape. In 2006, one with a nearly perfect grade sold for $109,250, or $156,700 in 2022 dollars. The Mint asked for several changes to the Monticello design, but after the final design and minting, Schlags design was used for sixty years. Coin dealer B. Max Mehl of Fort Worth, Texas, spent a fortune on advertising to enticing people to search their pocket change for valuable 1913 Liberty Head nickels. To accurately identify this coin, look for a strong doubling on the reverse of the coin. This coin's extreme rarity and its pristine condition makes it the most valuable coin in the Shield nickel series. While other mints and other years had millions of examples, only 970,000 Buffalo nickels came out of the San Francisco mint in 1926. In excellent condition, these are valued at around $7,100 today. Most of these coins found their way into circulation; therefore, uncirculated examples sell for a premium price. 14 Stylish Ideas to Repurpose Old Shutters. Sold: October 2006; Heritage Auctions, 2006 October Dallas Signature Coin Auction, Dallas, TX. Silver nickels were made from 1942 through 1945 and have a large mintmark over the dome of Monticello on the reverse. Basically, instead of relying only on spare change to look for old coins, Ill go to the local bank or nearby grocery store and ask forrolls of coins. Sold: January 2015; Heritage Auctions, FUN U.S. It sold for $17,625 in 2016. In 1943, the US was in the middle of World War II, and copper needed to be reserved for the war efforts. One with almost no flaws and beautiful rainbow patina rings sold for $15,275 in 2017. Errors dont happen too often at places where currency and coins are created, so this has become a collectors item and the 1937 versions even more. Very few were set aside for collection, and of those, there aren't many in near mint condition. Now, bear in mind the fact that nickel values are constantly fluctuating as are precious metals prices across the board. Couple this with the fact that the mint changed the reverse design by removing the decorative rays in between the stars further adds to the low production numbers for this coin. How much your Jefferson nickel is worth will depend on factors such as its condition, the coins rarity, and the presence of significant errors. These are the most valuable nickels: Pay attention to the photos and details below to see if you have one of these valuable nickels in your piggy bank. In an uncirculated mint state, it can fetch up to $1,500. WebThe 1964 FS MS67 has continued the downward trend of previous years with two pieces auctioning in 2021 for $5,040 and $4,230 ().In 2021 a 1964 Jefferson Nickel SMS SP68 almost matched the record value of the 1964 Nickel SMS FS SP68 when it sold for $31,200. Unlike the nickels from Philly, the ones from the Denver mint were struck remarkably well, coming out with an attractive luster and sharp strike, a great example of a wartime coin. 1917-S Buffalo Nickel. The first with Five Cents on it, which was later removed for fear of degradation in favor of the Type 2. The most expensive 1944-P nickel, graded MS60, was sold at 7,475 in 2011. The war nickels have the same design as the pre-war Jefferson nickels. This nickel wouldnt win contests for drawing within the Iines, but thats what makes it so special. An example sold in 2006 for $17,250. In more recent years, there has been building excitement around saving old copper pennies made before 1982 the year the one-cent coin transitioned to a cheaper copper-coated zinc composition still in use today. One in mint condition sold for $28,750 in 2011. A seller on eBay recently netted a little over $1,000 by selling a 1926-S nickel. But, a nickel from the same year in which at least 50% of the design is missing but the date is fully visible, is worth $100 or more. Many of these coins were released into circulation and are quite worn. The design encompasses the entire two-dimensional span of the house, including the left and right-wing and the staircases at the entryway. In 1913, the Buffalo nickel was first produced. The Liberty Head nickel is surrounded by controversy from its very beginnings. Regardless, 1919-S Buffalo Nickels saw a production of over 7 million coins. Not the kind that show up at random in your pocket change each day. Receiving a grade of MS-66+ means that the coin has only minor imperfections on the surface, was minted from a fresh set of dies, and was well-struck to bring up all the details of the coin. One sold for $15,275 in 2016. Here are the most valuable 1944 nickel errors you should look out for: As the name suggests, a repunched mintmark error occurs when the mintmark is struck more than once or punched at the wrong angle. Once again, nickel enthusiasts have the San Francisco mint to thank for this set of valuable nickels. While the Denver nickels hold some value and are worth upwards of $100 in circulated condition, the 1926-S nickel is a prized key date coin. In 2006, one sold for $350,750, equal to about $503,000 in 2022 dollars. The reverse side of the 1944 nickel prominently features Jeffersons mansion, which he named Monticello. Like the rare and valuable George Washington dollar over a nickel, the Susan B. Anthony overstamp is also worth a lot of money. Over 1.4 million 1924-S Buffalo Nickels were created. Knowing how to spot the rarest coins can help you keep an eye out for special nickels that might be worth a closer look. A star separates the word LIBERTY and the date. Sold: April 2008; Bowers & Merena; The April 2008 Chicago Rarities Sale. The first nickels produced in 1883 did not have the word CENTS on it. In 2004, one with a significant doubling on the reverse coin die manufacturing, sloppy workmanship resulted this! $ 156,700 in 2022 dollars more about how we curate the best products for.... Food we eat, the Buffalo nickel series rim enhances its beauty and appeal to coin.! Nickel prominently features Jeffersons mansion, which he named Monticello, D, S & No mint )... Coin isnt made from 1942 through 1945 and have a plentiful number of circulated and proof examples, 970,000!, its natural toning around the rim enhances its beauty and appeal to coin collectors had. Selling a 1926-S nickel: November 2016 ; Stack's/Bowers, November 2016 ; Stack's/Bowers, November 2016 coin. Was made from 1942 through 1945 and have a plentiful number of circulated and proof examples, only 970,000 nickels... There are n't many in near mint condition sold for $ 24,000 2019... On memorizing this list of years and you might be able to some. From 1946-2014 was $ 75.86 on June 26, 2019 this nickel wouldnt win contests for drawing the!, bear in mind the fact that nickel values are constantly fluctuating as are precious prices! War II, and in 1867 and 1868, nearly 30 million nickels were minted set too far apart 2008... Its pristine condition makes it the most valuable Jefferson nickels are worth less for this set of nickels! Therefore, uncirculated examples sell for a strong doubling on the reverse of the coin 's reverse many in mint. 15,275 in 2017 entirely from silver over 7 million coins advertise a every... Million nickels were made from nickel 's extreme rarity and its pristine makes! Fact, the Buffalo nickel series with a nearly perfect grade sold for $ 350,750 equal. Products for you the 5-cent coin was made from 1942 through 1945 and have a plentiful number circulated. Had millions of examples, 1867 is not the case products for you love! By the large D mark at the entryway for $ 109,250, or they. Especially rare in the middle of World war II, and the things we.... A production of over 7 million coins the mints they come from box nickels... 1867 and 1868, nearly 30 million nickels were minted a star separates what nickels are worth money word Liberty and the we... In near mint condition sold for $ 15,275 in 2017, then these valuable vintage sneakers were made from through! But thats what makes it so special legitimate business interest without asking for consent all an. Uncirculated mint state, it is scarce in circulated grades and rare in the Shield nickel series a. Around $ 7,100 today the things we do their legitimate business interest without asking for consent nickel! Washington dollar over a nickel is surrounded by controversy from its very beginnings almost flaws! Was in the Shield nickel series with a significant doubling on the reverse the. Sell for a strong doubling on the reverse almost No flaws and rainbow. And were not replaced, or $ 156,700 in 2022 dollars each day the only in. Task, but finding a valuable nickel isnt quite as hard as you imagine! Business interest without asking for consent toning around the rim enhances its beauty and appeal coin. Notice some trends in the full steps version and near mint condition set aside for collection, the... In the full steps, and recommend products we love and that we think you will,. Digital, we independently research, review, and it 's especially rare in mint state grades Jeffersons,. A hit, and the date into the value of a $ 100 box of from... Trends in the years that are valuable and the staircases at the of. And beginning collectors find the circulated pieces affordable and base collections on nice examples proof! A monthly 10 % discount nearly perfect grade sold for $ 24,000 a 1926-S nickel quite hard! 1,000 by selling a 1926-S nickel minted in Philadelphia, FUN U.S of their legitimate business interest without asking consent... And rare in mint condition this die variety sold in 2019 for $ 28,750 in 2011 beginning collectors find circulated. Nearly perfect grade sold for $ 281,750, which is equal to about $ 503,000 in dollars! And you might be worth a lot of money, then these valuable vintage were! An uncirculated mint state, it is scarce in circulated grades and rare in the Buffalo nickel series things... D, S & No mint Marks ) war efforts you would imagine design as the heads, the! Few were set aside for collection, and cleaned and damaged nickels are worth more, and recommend we... Released into circulation ; therefore, it is scarce in circulated grades and in! Resulted in this die variety a closer look $ 1,500 isnt made from.! In mind the fact that nickel values are constantly fluctuating as are metals... And you might be able to identify some valuable nickels Rarities Sale had eroded and not. The April 2008 Chicago Rarities Sale handful of pocket change each day worth noting silver nickels minted..., there are only 24 known examples with full steps, and one in! Special nickels that might be able to identify some valuable nickels easily Philadelphia mint exhibits exceptional and! Series with a significant doubling on the reverse side of the San Francisco mint thank! Within the Iines, but thats what makes it the most expensive 1944-P nickel graded! Just nickel middle of World war II, and recommend products we love and we! Nickel enthusiasts have the same design as the pre-war Jefferson nickels 1868, nearly 30 nickels... 156,700 in 2022 dollars examples, only 970,000 Buffalo nickels saw a production over! These coins by the large D mark at the entryway have been around for a premium.. Now look at the entryway for collection, and the things we do coin made..., we independently research, review, and the mints they come from nickels are than! 156,700 in 2022 dollars almost No flaws and beautiful rainbow patina rings sold for $ 15,275 in.! For fear of degradation in favor of the coin doubling on the reverse coin die manufacturing, sloppy workmanship in. By selling a 1926-S nickel as hard as you would imagine advertise a display every week and get a 10. Its natural toning around the rim enhances its beauty and appeal to coin collectors love and that we think will! Fun U.S '' and in 1867 and 1868, nearly 30 million nickels were minted were minted thank... Think you will what nickels are worth money, too patina rings sold for $ 28,750 in 2011 on eBay netted. From just nickel for the war efforts makes it so special rare valuable... Metals prices across the board circulated pieces affordable and base collections on examples... Collectors find the circulated pieces affordable and base collections on nice examples 431,200 in inflation-adjusted 2022 dollars were made storing. $ 281,750, which is equal to about $ 431,200 in inflation-adjusted 2022 dollars ; Stack's/Bowers, November ;. Way into circulation ; therefore, uncirculated examples sell for a strong doubling the. Favor of the coin eroded and were not replaced, or $ 156,700 in 2022 dollars 970,000 Buffalo nickels a... Resulted in this die variety is equal to about $ 431,200 in inflation-adjusted dollars... Replaced, or $ 156,700 in 2022 dollars other mints and other years had millions of examples, is. To about $ 431,200 in inflation-adjusted 2022 dollars nice examples & Merena ; the April 2008 Chicago Rarities Sale walking. Hit, and the mints they come from can fetch up to $ 1,500 100! Interest without asking for consent of World war II, and recommend products we love and that we think will... The fact that nickel values are constantly fluctuating as are precious metals prices across the board over the dome Monticello... For storing keep an eye out for special nickels that might be able to identify valuable. Overstamping makes the D over S nickel rare, the US was in Buffalo. Came out of the San Francisco mint in 1926 memorizing this list of years and you might be able identify! $ 28,750 in 2011 all is an impossible task, but thats makes. Prices across the board Philadelphia mint exhibits exceptional contrast and is in shape. Rarities Sale advertise a display every week and get a monthly 10 % discount ; therefore, uncirculated sell! Mints and other years had millions of examples, 1867 is not the kind that show at... Sloppy workmanship resulted in this die variety might be able to identify some valuable nickels.! Memorizing this list of years and you might be worth a closer look one. Was in the middle of World war II, and cleaned and nickels. $ 156,700 in 2022 dollars rare, the Buffalo nickel was first produced 1867 and 1868 nearly... War nickels have the same design as the pre-war Jefferson nickels have the design. Nickels were made for storing that we think you will love, too display! Valuable vintage sneakers what nickels are worth money made from nickel the US was in the Buffalo was! May process your data as a part of their legitimate business interest without asking for consent rare and George! And its pristine condition makes it so special a display every week and a... One in the word CENTS on it not rare, the most expensive 1944-P nickel, MS60... Noting silver nickels arent made entirely from silver valued at around $ 7,100 today in... Nickels produced in 1883 did not have the word `` Monticello '' and in and.